Choose your path
Find An Appraiser         Online Store         Donate         Lum Library         Join
 View Cart View Cart
0 Registrations in Cart
Appraisal Institute  
AI Resources Education Publications Professional Practice News Advocacy About Us
Select an Offering

4TH ANNUAL JOINT LUNCHEON WITH IRWA CHAPTER 57 - A Tale of Two Cities Condemnations of Private Water Companies: Valuation Aspects (Cities of Ojai and Claremont)

CALL   Date: April 4, 2018   Location: Riverside, CA
  Local Area Topics  
Category  Electives [E]  
Attendance Hours  2.0  
Current Price  $ 35.00 *  
* includes late fee
Late Fee  $ 10.00  
Name  Marriott Riverside  
Address  3400 Market St.  
City  Riverside  
State  CA  
Zip  92501  
  Sponsor / Contact  
Chapter  Southern California
Contact Name  Lianna Ayala  
Phone  (818) 957-5111x2  

Jeffrey M. Oderman
Rutan & Tucker, LLP

Wayne Lusvardi
Bruce W. Hull MAI and Associates

Bruce W. Hull, MAI
Bruce W. Hull, MAI and Associates

Jeffrey Oderman is a partner in the firm's Government and Regulatory Section, where he practices in the areas of municipal law, land use, environmental law, eminent domain, and related public agency litigation. Mr. Oderman is also a member of the firm’s Land Use and Natural Resources Practice Group, the Affordable Housing and Economic Development Practice Group, and the Condemnation/Property Valuation Practice Group. Mr. Oderman represents both public agency and private clients within his areas of expertise. Mr. Oderman joined Rutan & Tucker in 1977 and has been a partner since 1980. Mr. Oderman served as Rutan & Tucker’s Managing Partner from 1995-1998 and from 2002-2005. Mr. Oderman also served on the Firm’s Executive Committee from 1995-2005 and as the Chairperson of the Firm’s Government & Regulatory Law Section. 

Wayne Lusvardi was chief real estate appraiser for the Metropolitan Water District for 20 years and has authored numerous articles in The Appraisal Journal (MAI), Right of Way magazine (IRWA), Real Estate Review Journal (NYU), Journal of Property Economics (IAAO), Real Estate Issues (CRE), and Public Utilities Fortnightly (PUR). Wayne specializes in the valuation of regulated investor-owned water utilities and water rights, the valuation of marketized fiber optic easements, overlapping easements within utility corridors, telecommunications real estate and complex eminent domain valuation assignments. He developed the three methods of real estate damage valuation (Deduction, Adduction, Reduction). He is an associate with Bruce W. Hull, MAI, and Associates and resides in Rancho Mirage, California. 

Bruce Hull is a qualified expert appraisal witness in the superior courts of Los Angeles, Orange, Riverside and Ventura counties and the U.S. District Court in Los Angeles and the Central District of California.  His specialization has been in the valuation of large land secured dirt bond (Mello Roos) financing for master planned communities for bond underwriters. Bruce was on the advisory panel in developing Appraisal Standards for Land Secured Financing by the California Debt Advisory Commission.

TOPIC: In 2013 and 2014 parallel, but independent, efforts were launched by two California cities to get government water agencies to takeover private water companies regulated by the CPUC in order to lower water rates, with diametrically different outcomes.

In 2013 the City of Ojai voted in favor of a plan for the Casitas Municipal Water District to takeover by condemnation Golden State Water Company with about 3,200 water service connections. Casitas Water District’s appraisal was $23.7 million plus non-operating accounts totaling about $28 million ($8,750 per water connection) and involved estimating a premium for the public takeover of a private water company, the only such provision in case law.

In 2014, the City of Claremont also initiated an effort to condemn Golden State Water Company’s system in their community serving about 11,000 connections. Claremont’s appraisal was $55 million ($5,000/connection) while Golden State’s appraised value was $222 million ($20,182/connection). 

In contrast, by 2016 Superior Court Judge Richard Fruin denied Claremont’s public necessity to acquire Golden State Water’s system in its city, mainly due to lack of evidence that water rates could be lowered.  Claremont spent about $14 million in litigation costs in a losing effort to establish a public necessity to take over Golden State’s system.  This was nearly double the city’s general fund reserve account.’

To make sense of the divergent outcomes of the recent high profile Ojai and Claremont cases, Jeff Oderman, legal counsel for Casitas Municipal Water District and partner of the Costa Mesa law firm of Rutan and Tucker and , will speak.  Also speaking will be Wayne Lusvardi, former Chief Appraiser at the Metropolitan Water District of Southern California, and Bruce Hull, MAI, who will address the unique issue of how to estimate a premium required under eminent domain law when a public entity buys out a private water company.  Lusvardi and Hull will hand out an original article on the topic, which will be published in the Right of Way magazine.
Cancellation Policy
  • Up To 15 days prior to program start date, $5.00 cancellation fee.
  • 2 - 14 days prior to program start date, $15.00 cancellation fee.
  • Less than 2 days prior to program start date, forfeit of payment.
This Educational Program (Program) was developed and organized by the Appraisal Institute Chapter offering the Program with the intent of addressing topic(s) of current local interest solely for educational and informational purposes. The Appraisal Institute national organization was not involved in developing or organizing the Program.

The content of this Program, including but not limited to any written materials and presenter comments, does not represent the viewpoint of the Appraisal Institute (defined as including but not limited to, the national organization, its Regions, Chapters, members, candidates, affiliates and staff) unless formally adopted by the national Board of Directors. Further, the Appraisal Institute has not peer-reviewed or approved the content of the Program and does not warrant the accuracy or timeliness of the content of the Program. The content of the Program is subject to court decisions and local, state and federal laws and regulations and any such revisions of such laws and regulations.

This Program is presented with the understanding that the Appraisal Institute is not engaged in rendering legal, accounting or other professional advice or services. Nothing in the Program is to be construed as the offering of such advice or services. If expert advice or services are required, attendees and readers are responsible for obtaining such advice or services from appropriate professionals.

Enrollment is on a first-come, first served basis. If the event is filled, a waiting list will be retained. The Southern California Chapter reserves the rights to cancel, limit, or reschedule this event if the minimum enrollment level is not reached, and to change faculty assignments and facility locations at any time. Prospective students should confirm their registration before making any non-refundable airline reservations. There are NO transfers; you must cancel out of the offering.

The Appraisal Institute enforces attendance requirements mandated by state licensing and certification regulatory agencies. The Appraisal Institute issues certificates for state certification/licensing or state continuing education credit that verify successful completion and attendance of 100%, with your grade notification letter for courses, or at the conclusion of seminars. One hundred percent (100%) attendance is required for all Appraisal Institute education programs. This follows Appraiser Qualification Board minimum criteria requirements.

Some classes have prerequisites. Be sure to read the course description to find out if there are any prerequisites for this course.

Some classes have required textbooks. Be sure to read the class description to find out if there are any required textbooks for this course. There will not be any textbooks for purchase at the class. You must buy them ahead of time. If you arrive for a class without the required textbook credit for the class cannot be given and there will be no refund.

Some classes require you bring a laptop and or other equipment. Be sure to read the class description to determine if any equipment is required. You are responsible for bringing your own extension cord(s). None will be provided. Please safeguard your equipment and personal belongings at all times. The Appraisal Institute, the Southern California Chapter, the Instructor or the facility will not be responsible for any loss of your personal belongings.

Some classes are now available with downloadable materials. If you opted to download class materials instead of having them shipped to you, you will be required to bring the materials with you on a laptop or as a hard copy. If you do not have the materials with you credit for the class cannot be given and there will be no refund. Copies will not be available to you in the class. You are responsible for bringing your own extension cord(s). None will be provided.

It is the policy of the Appraisal Institute to provide reasonable accommodations for qualified persons with disabilities who are participating in Appraisal Institute educational programs. If you need accommodations to participate because of a disability, please notify us in writing at least two weeks in advance of the program and we will arrange for reasonable accommodation. Without two weeks’ notice, accommodation may not be available.

For scannable exams, written notification of results will be sent to the examinee approximately 15 business days from the date of receipt of the exams at the national office.
Certificates of completion for continuing education will be sent to the student in approximately 15 days from the date of the class. Express Grading is available. For more information contact the national office at (312)335-4207.

Program materials will be picked up at the site.
  Additional Information  






Appraisal Institute
200 W. Madison, Suite 1500, Chicago, IL 60606
888-7JOINAI (756-4624)  |
Contact Us   |   Site Map   |   Terms & Conditions   |   Privacy Policy   |   Advertise
  Copyright © 2017 Appraisal Institute. All rights reserved.